EMIL 

FRANZI 

Paperwork 'default' may be behind rise of 'independents'

August 29, 2007


RECENT FRANZI:

A short list of our 'problem children'

Making sense of capital punishment's surroundings issues

Being a red state guarantees nothing

"Culture’ no excuse for Vick’s dogfighting

There are things worse than a Wal-Mart

They're in the starting gate for OV council, legislative races

ORO VALLEY FIRST MEET DISTRICT 26

Best political leadership comes from center

Let's get back to real representation

When did supervisors become onlookers?

Az. GOP 'hang tough,' not hang each other

'Re-defining' the immigration debate

Culling the GOP's presidential herd

You pick them; they don't pick you

Marana's 'good ol' boy' days soon to end

MCCAIN RECONSIDERED

Reactions to Imus' demise raise bigger issues

produces myths, postures

Fixing government's 'functional breakdown'

Three local elections to keep your eyes on

Elected officials perfectly at ease on sidelines

Recounting my three biggest blunders

Some aren't worth minimum wage

Pathology and porn at the local library

Inside Track: Marana faces some imperfect options

Inside Track: Wealthy people have to live someplace

Inside Track: The nanny state will now address - annoyance

Why 'consensus' is a dangerous concept

Why can't Republicans just say 'No?'

Dumb political clichès

Check back in ’08 to see how it turns out

My own Iraq study group

A handful of holiday opinions

Real GOP doesn't use elections welfare

Give 'em a reason not to vote for the other guy

Conscription anathema to a free society

A chronicle of cluelessness, post Nov. 7

What we can take from the election

Six basic views of the war in Iraq

Graf, GOP gave CD8 to Giffords

Three cheers for John Philip Sousa

The insider's take on 18 ballot props

PRINCIPLE VERSUS PRECEDENT

Parsing the state ballot propositions

How not to run a campaign for office

Why voters vote for a candidate

Oro Valley's hidden agenda?

Inside Track: Franzi prognosticates the primary

Searching for the NW's political stalker

A tale of political pariahs

Annexation is a shabby process

RINO is not synonymous with liberal Republican

There is no such thing as free money

If only more pundits were more like Mike

Election may end D26's RINO days

Whose side are the two Times on?

More handicapping of primary elections

Coulter no worse than her attackers

The inside track on September 12

The Western is dead, will it rise again?

Whining, from the left and right

Voting lottery an insult to voting rights

Harry was right to drop the A-bomb

Ethics training for public officials?

Don't reward people too lazy to vote  

Ain't no room for Right in AZ schools

The inside track on the May election

More bipartisan immigration myths

You can't run government like a business

In requiem: Hannibal Franzi, 1988? - 2006

Getting real on voting fraud

Decrying pathological egalitariansim

Bring back partisan local elections  

Why it's called 'Inside Track'

Italian-American cultural history 101

Dispelling illegal immigration myths

The sky will not fall; vote 'No' on Question 2

SOME THOUGHTS ON ISRAEL  (pre-Iraq invasion)

The road to nowhere

Bemoaning vote-at-home

Beware liberal boogy men

The rising cost of politics

Talk radio myths

Another stab at decrying policy by bureaucracy

Bet on Latas as the Democrat Dark Horse

The tail wags the dog in local government

Handicapping the CD8 Democratic race

Handicapping the GOP race to replace Kolbe

Cowardly town manager vote puts Sweet in a tight box

Miers sunk Miers' nomination, not the 'Extreme Right'

Chris Limberis: Reporter

When it comes to poverty, look at who's exploiting who

Column critics wrong

Democracy ain't the same everywhere

Save a buck, let 'em vote

A wildcat misnomer

 

The latest voter registration numbers for Arizona are in, and it seems “independents” now outnumber both major parties by 53 percent to 47 percent. There are mechanical reasons for that as well as disdain for the two major parties.

No doubt both Democrats and Republicans are in trouble with all voters. While the President’s favorability index hovers around 30 percent, one recent poll had the Democratic Congress down to 14 percent. Twelve percent believes Elvis is still alive. Still, not quite as bad as Israeli Prime Minister Ohmert. On a 600-person sample survey he registered only 3 percent, which was lower than the margin of error.

There is a reason beyond partisan dissatisfaction for high independent numbers. More than half of the independents, at least in Pima County, are actually classed as NOP for “no organized party.” As the Greens and Libertarians are organized, I thought about a quarter of the electorate registering “Tupperware” and “Whig” was a bit much.

Turns out it is. Pima County Voter Registrar Chris Roads explained “NOP” voters are those who failed to put anything in the block on the voter registration form marked for political party choice. State law does not require one be made. Some of those marked NOP are in fact DEMS and REPS and probably a few LBTs and GRNs who simply didn’t fill in the line. Anyone registering with a real non-organized party is classified as a Communist or Federalist or whatever they chose.

This is a direct result in the change in the voter registration system some years back that allowed for self-registration. Previously, a deputy voter registrar signed up a voter. MVD workers and others, usually from the political parties and duly sworn in and rudimentarily trained, were the principle sources of new voters. They would see to it all blocks were covered. Interestingly, the now-obsolete reason for having voters write the party preference themselves was to prohibit zealous partisans from slipping in the choice for them. Most of the NOPs would probably pick a block if they were simply given the normal run of choices including “other” and “independent.”

California had and may still have the choice “decline to state,” which I always thought was the ultimate for weenies.

What probably drives non-partisan registration up even more is the ability extended by a craven GOP legislature and their egalitarian Democratic allies a few years back that opened both major party primaries to independents and NOPs. This helped contribute to the slow suicide of both parties by making them even more irrelevant in declaiming how little they really thought of themselves by allowing anybody to pick their candidates. I recognize some other states have done this for years, but that hardly justifies it.

The GOP types mostly supported it because they were worried an even worse version would get on the ballot. Successfully fighting dumb ballot propositions has never been a Republican strong suit. Democrats either were dazzled by it or more likely were pandering to goody-two-shoes editorial writers at the mainstream dailies who slobber over this stuff.

On Feb. 3, Arizona will join 20 or so other states in a cheap attempt to bag a few advertising bucks and candidate appearances by holding an earlier presidential primary. Big problem: The same statute that sets up primaries for all other offices in September doesn’t cover this primary. Per the Republican National Committee, GOP registration is mandatory for participation in the presidential choice. (Democrats are looser — in other ways, too.)

Because the GOP legislative leadership and the Democratic minority didn’t think about housekeeping, some legit Republican voters who didn’t fill out all of a form will be denied access to their party’s presidential nominating process.

A simple change mandating a check-off block for party choice will help solve it in the future.

And a little more thought and less panic on the part of all legislators would be a big help, too.


 


 


BACK TO TOP


EMIL FRANZI

EMAIL FRANZI

BUT WATCH WHAT YOU SAY!

About Emil Franzi

Emil Franzi is the owner and host of "Inside Track" on KVOI - 690AM and KAPR - 930AM in Douglas.  The program airs on Saturdays from 12 pm till 5 pm.

Franzi currently writes a weekly column for the EXPLORER (formerly the NORTHWEST EXPLORER). He filled the TUCSON WEEKLY with close to a million relevant words from 1993 to 2004 and was an OpEd regular with the Az Daily Star from 1994 to 1998. His writing has also appeared in PHOENIX Magazine, ARIZONA HIGHWAYS, and the late CITY MAGAZINE in Tucson.

But then, Franzi is an iconoclast.

This website is Franzi's baby, put together with work, faith, and a little help from his friends, like Tom Danehy, Joyce Downey and Mike Tully.  The concept -- politics, books, humor, the Old West, movies, "Pet Talk" and letters -- is Emil's.  This unique brew seems to work.  This website averages more than a thousand "hits" a day and keeps growing.

You can read Emil Franzi's views on all things political and cultural, as well as opposing views, on our "Politics and More" page.